Search for Missing New Zealand Monk Justin Evans Enters Second Week in Orkney
Scottish police extend the search for 24-year-old monk Justin Evans (Brother Ignatius) on Papa Stronsay, despite a "presumed death" notice from the local Diocese.
By: AXL Media
Published: Apr 17, 2026, 3:30 AM EDT
Source: RNZ Pacific
Conflict Over "Presumed Death" and Search Status
A significant discrepancy emerged on Friday between law enforcement and religious officials. The Diocese of Aberdeen issued a statement expressing "deep sadness" over the disappearance and presumed death of Evans, suggesting he had come to harm in the sea and that searches had been concluded. However, Inspector David Hall of the Scottish Police clarified shortly after that extensive searches remain active. Specialist resources and partner agencies are currently focused on the coastal areas of Papa Stronsay and the neighboring island of Stronsay, with plans to continue operations well into next week.
The Reclusive Community of Papa Stronsay
Evans had been living for two years as a member of the Sons of the Holy Redeemer, a traditionalist Catholic order that purchased Papa Stronsay in 1999. The island serves as a secluded sanctuary where the monks are the sole inhabitants, living in a restored monastery. While the order is famously reclusive, members are occasionally seen in the main harbor of Kirkwall for supplies. Local residents noted that while the island is isolated, it is possible to wade between Papa Stronsay and Stronsay during low tide, though leaving the area entirely without local assistance is considered nearly impossible.
Personal Background and Tributes from Christchurch
Before his religious calling took him to the North Sea, Evans was a well-known figure at Christchurch’s St Bede’s College. Rector Jon McDowall remembered him as a "charismatic leader" who was highly respected across his peer group and the wider religious community. News of his disappearance has hit the Christchurch community hard, with former teachers and classmates offering prayers for his safe return. Father Michael Mary, the founder of the order on Papa Stronsay, described the situation as "utterly tragic," noting that the close-knit monastic community is deeply hurting.