Ohio Man Apprehended in Michigan Following Violent Attempted Robbery Over Kentucky Vehicle Dispute

Tony Deccola was arrested in Michigan for a Paducah attempted robbery involving a rifle and a vehicle dispute. He now faces extradition to Kentucky.

By: AXL Media

Published: Mar 9, 2026, 3:30 PM EDT

Source: The information in this article was sourced from KFVS12

A Violent Confrontation Over a Private Automotive Sale

The Paducah Police Department launched a criminal investigation last week following a reported assault in the 1500 block of Blow Avenue. According to law enforcement officials, the conflict originated from a transaction involving the sale of a vehicle. Tony Deccola, an Ohio resident, allegedly returned to the buyer’s residence shortly after the deal was finalized. Upon his arrival, investigators state that Deccola issued a localized ultimatum, demanding that the victim either return the vehicle or provide additional monetary compensation beyond the agreed-upon price.

Escalation to Armed Assault in a Residential Neighborhood

The situation transitioned from a verbal dispute to a violent felony when Deccola allegedly brandished a .22-caliber rifle. Police reports indicate that the suspect did not merely use the firearm as a deterrent but instead utilized it as a blunt force object. Deccola is accused of pointing the weapon at the victim and striking him multiple times, resulting in injuries significant enough to require professional medical intervention. The victim was subsequently transported to a regional hospital for treatment of his wounds, while the assailant fled the scene before local officers could arrive.

Federal Task Force Coordinates Multi-State Fugitive Search

Following the identification of the suspect and the severity of the assault, Kentucky authorities secured an arrest warrant charging Deccola with attempted first-degree robbery. Recognizing that the suspect had likely crossed state lines to evade capture, the United States Marshals Service Fugitive Task Force was mobilized to assist in the manhunt. The collaborative effort between local and federal agencies tracked the 32-year-old suspect several hundred miles north of the original crime scene.