Nicky Butt Reveals Paul Scholes Is ‘Shocked and Gutted’ Over Misinterpreted Social Media Critique of Michael Carrick

Nicky Butt reveals Paul Scholes is "gutted" over the reaction to his Michael Carrick comments, calling the post a tongue-in-cheek joke.

By: AXL Media

Published: Mar 13, 2026, 10:26 AM EDT

Source: Information for this report was sourced from Football365

A Social Media Outburst Sparks Internal Turmoil

The initial optimism surrounding Michael Carrick’s interim tenure at Manchester United has faced a significant reality check following a string of disappointing performances and a 2-1 defeat to ten-man Newcastle United. In the immediate aftermath of the loss, Paul Scholes ignited a firestorm on Instagram by suggesting the team had been underperforming for several weeks despite their earlier results. The comment, which implied that Carrick’s success might be more a product of fortune than tactical dominance, drew sharp criticism from supporters who viewed the remark as an unnecessary attack on a former teammate during a vulnerable period for the club.

The Pundit’s Private Move to Restore Relations

In an effort to mitigate the damage caused by his digital outburst, Scholes reportedly initiated direct contact with Carrick to explain the intent behind his words. Speaking on a recent podcast, Scholes emphasized that he holds Carrick in the highest regard, describing him as one of the most respected individuals in the sport. The former midfielder insisted that his message was not intended to be offensive and claimed that Carrick personally assured him that no offense was taken. This private reconciliation highlights a desire to maintain the unity of the "Class of 92" era even as they transition into often-conflicting roles as pundits and coaches.

Nicky Butt Defends the Character of his Former Teammate

Nicky Butt has provided further context to the situation, suggesting that those who do not know Scholes personally are prone to misinterpreting his dry and often blunt communication style. Butt argued that Scholes was essentially remarking on the necessity of luck for any successful manager, rather than questioning Carrick’s fundamental competence. According to Butt, the realization that his comments were perceived as a personal slight has left Scholes feeling "shocked and gutted," as he remains one of Carrick’s most vocal supporters in his bid to secure the permanent managerial role at Old Trafford.