Lily Collins Reunited with Custom Engagement Ring Three Years After Spa Burglary

Actress Lily Collins reveals she is speechless after her custom Irene Neuwirth engagement ring, stolen in 2023, was returned by a Chicago jewelry store.

By: AXL Media

Published: Mar 7, 2026, 7:14 AM EST

Source: People

A Rare Recovery in a High-Profile Burglary Case

The saga began on May 6, 2023, when Collins reported a burglary at the Edition Hotel on Sunset Boulevard in West Hollywood. While the actress was enjoying a session at the hotel spa, her belongings—including her engagement ring, wedding band, and other luxury items—were taken from a secured locker. At the time, the Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department estimated the total value of the stolen property to exceed 10,000 dollars. The recovery of such specific jewelry years after a theft is considered an unusual success in celebrity crime investigations.

The Significance of the Rose-Cut Diamond

The returned item is a unique rose cut diamond ring designed by Irene Neuwirth. When McDowell proposed in September 2020, the ring gained immediate attention for its non-traditional, translucent aesthetic. Collins previously described the "rock" as exactly what she had always wanted, praising McDowell for his deep understanding of her personal style. The return of the "original" ring is particularly meaningful as it was the specific piece used during their engagement in the US & Canada region.

Jewelry Firm Plays Key Role in Return

While the specific details of how the ring was identified were not fully disclosed, Collins credited Hakimian Imports Chicago Jewelers with the return of the jewelry. It is common for high-end jewelers to play a role in identifying stolen pieces that surface in the secondary market or during estate sales. Collins shared a selfie with the ring back on her finger, stating that "having this home means SO much to us" and that she remained speechless over the turn of events.