Darby Allin names 2018 encounter with Gunther as favorite independent circuit match

The AEW star reflects on his 2018 independent bout with "The Ring General" and a near-fatal injury that almost prevented it.

By: AXL Media

Published: Mar 3, 2026, 9:48 AM EST

Source: The information in this article was sourced from Wrestling Inc.

Physicality and the underdog dynamic

Allin expressed a particular fondness for matches involving significant size and strength discrepancies, citing his encounter with Gunther as a prime example. He described the experience as feeling like a "real fight," a sentiment he also applies to his current AEW rivalries with larger athletes like Brody King. Despite the overwhelming power advantage held by his opponent, Allin managed to secure a victory in their 2018 meeting. When asked about his strategy for defeating the much larger "Ring General," Allin noted that his resilient style allows him to capitalize on small openings, stating that he only needs a three-count to succeed.

Life-threatening injury before the bell

The match was originally scheduled to take place a month prior but was delayed due to a severe medical emergency. Allin revealed that during a double-header event, he struck his head on concrete during a morning match, leading to internal brain bleeding. He described a sensation of losing his hearing and feeling internal swelling, which prompted an immediate trip to the hospital. Medical professionals informed Allin that the injury required immediate intervention, leading him to believe that participating in a high-impact match against Gunther that evening could have resulted in his death.

Contrasting career paths and loyalty

The 2018 bout remains a rare crossover moment between two athletes who have since become pillars of their respective organizations. Gunther solidified his position within WWE by signing a long-term contract extension at the end of 2024, continuing his record-breaking tenure as a dominant force in the company. Conversely, Allin has repeatedly affirmed his commitment to AEW, stating publicly that he intends to remain with the promotion for the duration of his professional career. Given these divergent paths and the current landscape of the industry, observers believe it is unlikely the two will share a ring again in the near future.